I agree that they should make a movie. It would seem appropriate- this is a very good series. I love it. PS TEAM SHAY!!!!! 💖

I loved these books I have read the first two in 2 days.... On to the third! PS: MAKE A MOVIE!!! Please!!

Best book ever! ;)

This book is amazing. I absolutely loved the first book and the sequel was just as good. I didn't have any problems with the books but with the fans. A lot of people have been freaking out about the love triangle of the series, if you even call it that. In Nightshade, there wasn't enough detail about Ren to choose a side in the love triangle. It's obvious that the author meant for Calla to end up with Shay, not Ren. She spends most of the book with Shay. The only reason I'm talking about this is because crazy fans have been constantly bashing fans who are on Team Shay.

less romance, which kinda disappointed me alittle, but still a thriller! tons of exciting twist and turns that will keep you on edge. couldn't stop reading! TEAM SHAY !<3

Loved it!!

i can't believe Ren didn't know about his mother died or his real father, it would be cool if the Andrea can make of movie of the series. i like Team Calla and Shay. i'll chose Team Shay^_^.

Yay can't wait until the next book

I LOVE this book and all the thrills it holds. It keeps you reading and is amazingly written. I do not understand why people hate Shay though. I like both Ren and Shay and both of them have good and bad things about them. I cannot wait to see what Calla does in Bloodrose!

This book is the best!